China's Methanol Engine: Innovation or Diversion?

China''s Geely has introduced a 130 hp internal combustion engine that runs on methanol, touting it as a cleaner, more efficient alternative to hydrogen fuel cells and battery-electric vehicles (BEVs). The engine, developed as part of Geely''s push into carbon-neutral fuels, claims thermal efficiency of over 46%, fast refueling, and compatibility with existing ICE infrastructure. But does it truly offer a sustainable path forward?

China's Geely has introduced a 130 hp internal combustion engine that runs on methanol, touting it as a cleaner, more efficient alternative to hydrogen fuel cells and battery-electric vehicles (BEVs). The engine, developed as part of Geely's push into carbon-neutral fuels, claims thermal efficiency of over 46%, fast refueling, and compatibility with existing ICE infrastructure. But does it truly offer a sustainable path forward?

Methanol: Sourcing and Sustainability

Methanol can be produced either from fossil fuels—primarily natural gas or coal—or from renewable sources, known as "green methanol." Green methanol production uses renewable electricity to power electrolyzers that split water into hydrogen, which is then combined with captured CO₂ to synthesize methanol. This method can reduce lifecycle emissions by up to 90% compared to fossil fuels.

In Inner Mongolia, China is scaling up green methanol production. Several large-scale projects are underway, including one in Ordos aiming to produce over 100,000 metric tons annually. These initiatives harness abundant wind and solar power to drive hydrogen production, with carbon captured from industrial sources, making the fuel genuinely renewable.

Environmental Impact: Toxicity and Spill Risk

Unlike petroleum, which floats on water, methanol is fully miscible—meaning it dissolves entirely in water. While this reduces the risk of visible surface spills, it makes containment and cleanup far more difficult. Methanol is acutely toxic to aquatic life and can create hypoxic zones by depleting oxygen as it biodegrades. Although it breaks down more quickly than petroleum, its impact during that period can be significant and dangerous to ecosystems.

Efficiency and Emissions: Methanol vs Hydrogen and BEVs

In terms of energy efficiency, methanol lags far behind battery-electric technology. While it offers fast refueling and can leverage existing infrastructure, its conversion losses from electricity to hydrogen to methanol make it less viable for personal transport. Hydrogen fuel cells also struggle with efficiency and infrastructure but perform better in specific sectors like long-haul transport.

Conclusion

Geely’s methanol engine represents an intriguing engineering solution and a potentially valuable transitional technology, especially in regions where EV infrastructure is limited. However, its environmental benefits depend entirely on the source of methanol. When produced from renewables with captured CO₂, methanol can help decarbonize difficult-to-electrify sectors. But when derived from fossil fuels, it risks perpetuating carbon-intensive practices under a greenwashed guise.

For methanol to play a credible role in clean mobility, stricter standards around feedstock sourcing, emissions accounting, and spill mitigation will be essential.

Sources:

• Rude Baguette article on Geely's methanol engine
• Methanol Institute & Aramco joint report
• Zero Carbon Shipping – e-methanol
• Wikipedia – Methanol Economy
• Green H2 on Geely’s green methanol venture
• Towngas press release on Mongolian JV

Views: 191